Schedule a free consultation 212-566- 1000

Informational Blogs

Amtrak Train Crash in Philadelphia - Why You Need a Lawyer

Posted by Joseph F. Sullivan | May 20, 2015 | 0 Comments

The May 12, 2015 crash of an Amtrak train traveling from Washington D.C. to New York City is the latest in a series of recent train accidents that could have been prevented. This accident was tragically similar to the Metro-North derailment that took place in the Bronx in December of 2013. In both cases, the train operators failed to reduce the speed of the train as it was entering a curve and the excessive speed caused the train to derail. While the train operator certainly has the responsibility to be alert and maintain control of the train, Amtrak must also take responsibility for this tragedy because the technology exists to prevent these exact types of crashes.

News reports indicate that the Amtrak 188 was traveling in excess of 100 mph as it entered a curve with a designated speed limit of 50 mph. Positive Train Control Systems monitor the speed of a train along the track and can automatically slow the train in the event the operator becomes disabled. In fact, this system was installed on the track in the area of the accident but was not activated. Amtrak has put forth various bureaucratic and budgetary excuses for this state of affairs, none of which can justify the loss of life and devastation that has been wrought on the victims of this latest crash.

Congress has mandated the implementation of positive train control systems by the end of 2015, but the rail industry has resisted these safety measures and is pushing for an extension of the deadline until 2020. It's not clear how many more lives have to be lost and how much more harm needs to be inflicted upon our communities before the rail industry sees the cost of these measures as economically justified. There is no question that these systems are costly, but what is the value of the lives lost and families shattered in preventable wrecks like this?

Too often, the public takes a dim view of individuals that file a personal injury lawsuit. They don't always appreciate the value of such lawsuits in making our communities safer and forcing multi-million and multi-billion dollar industries to see the economic benefit of implementing safety measures. Sadly, the economic cost of many lives lost often does not outweigh the cost of safety measures in the eyes of corporate executives and bureaucrats focused solely on the bottom line. No doubt Amtrak investigators, risk managers, and attorneys have already begun preparing its defense to the lawsuits that will be coming. The cost of this disaster alone may not justify the cost of implementing positive train control systems, but victims will, and should, likewise seek legal representation. Their lawyers should ban together to take on Amtrak's defense and send a message to Amtrak, and the entire rail industry, that the time has come to stop making excuses and to implement this life-saving technology.

Joseph F. Sullivan, of Sullivan & Brill, LLP, represents victims of mass transit disasters and other accidents. For a free consultation, call 212-566-1000 or visit their website

About the Author

Joseph F. Sullivan

Born in Jamaica, Queens to working class parents, Joseph Sullivan became the second member of his family to attend college and the first to obtain an advanced degree. He graduated cum laude from Temple University School of Law. While there, he was a writer and editor of the Temple Law Review. ...


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Areas We Serve

Our firm serves clients throughout New York State, including New York City, Buffalo, Rochester, Binghamton, Albany, Syracuse, and Long Island.

Nav Map